First of all i congratulate Vossen and Anvab for their fresh and unique design and they deserve to be on winner's list today, But not the others because they're not even a have good design!
I think it is very unprofessional and poor judgment, because it looks that Jess Ng never used or opened original Apple iTunes before. It is clear when you make someone on 3rd place because of it's great idea! you have to actually have a great idea and concept, 3rd place is already redesigned and downgraded iTunes to it's crappy version of current iTunes, How do you even doubt about that? the current design is far more cleaner and polished than this one! sorry MasdikaStudio but you have to face the truth one way or another!
"Having the music list displaying on the same page would solve a lot of problems around page load. It's definitely an interesting concept to try out." ( Jess Said)
well dear jury, it is already tried out by Apple itself for more than a year or two! here how music list look like in current version of Apple iTunes:
MasdikaStudio entry:
and the 1st place to Saerox? are you kidding me? it looks like Admin Panels on ThemeForest! it doesnt represent the unique style and users of iTunes and Mac. why do you even think this design should be on winner's list and not only that but you think this design deserves 1st place?
Showing this that jury doesn't even know anything about original iTunes make this Challenge a fail. Envato should consider about how Jess Ng as a UX designer could be a good choice for judging this challenge and missed the most obvious things about UI/UX.
I don't want to insult anybody and even if I won Grand Prize and these designs (Saerox,MasdikaStudio,MYFW) on winner's list i write the same reply here.Because they brought none creativity and unique idea and they just facelift the current version to the worst one actually. I just want to tell you that if you want to be a good designer you have to try more than that, and what's not good is not good even if you win anything and you better know in a more professional workplaces ( not Envato actually ) you will fail with this kind of crap entry.
Once again good luck to Anvab & Vossen you totally nailed it.
from Envato Forums - Latest posts http://ift.tt/29bwnXH
via IFTTT
No comments:
Post a Comment